Are Supplements Worth It? What Works and What Doesn't
In today's world, the market is flooded with supplements promising everything from rapid fat loss to immense muscle gains. The harsh reality is that 95% of these supplements are pure junk. Among the 5% that are effective, 99% of companies overhype their benefits. However, there are a few supplements backed by hundreds, if not thousands, of studies demonstrating their efficacy and safety. These supplements have consistently shown to improve lean body mass, strength, and performance across various populations and conditions. This blog aims to shed light on the few supplements that truly work and debunk the myths surrounding those that don't.
Effective Supplements
1. Whey Protein
Whey protein is a staple in the health & fitness community for several reasons:
Convenient and High-Quality Protein Source: Whey protein is a fast and efficient way to meet your protein needs, making it an excellent supplement for muscle repair and growth.
Great Taste: Most whey protein products come in a variety of flavors, making them a tasty addition to your diet.
Cost-Effective: Whey protein is relatively inexpensive compared to other protein sources.
Protein needs:
Protein intake needed for maintenance: 0.8g/kg bodyweight
Protein intake needed to build muscle mass: 1.6-2.5g/kg bodyweight
For those without gastrointestinal (GI) issues or lactose intolerance, whey protein concentrate is sufficient. If you have GI issues or prefer to minimize carbs and fats, whey isolate is a better option as it contains more protein per gram and less lactose and fat.
See more information about how much protein you need in a previous post. The Protein Puzzle: How Much Protein Do You Really Need?
Suggested Protein Supplement : PERFECT SPORTS DIESEL
2. Creatine
Creatine monohydrate is the king of supplements:
Most Tested and Proven: No supplement has been tested more, with better results consistently, in the scientific literature for increasing lean body mass and increasing strength.
Cost-Effective: Creatine monohydrate is cheap and effective.
This is why supplement companies are always trying to come out with new forms of creatine so they can charge you more. But creatine monohydrate has been shown to saturate the muscle cell’s 100 percent. You don’t need anything else. Don’t waste your money on anything else.
Suggested Creatine Supplement : ALLMAX CREATINE MONOHYDRATE
3. Caffeine
Caffeine might not be glamorous, but it is incredibly effective:
Immediate Performance Boost: Caffeine improves focus and performance almost instantly.
Tolerance and Reset: You can build up a tolerance, so it's beneficial to periodically reset your tolerance by abstaining from caffeine for about a week.
Caffeine is one of the most effective supplements available, especially if you're looking for an immediate boost in performance. To maintain its effectiveness, it's beneficial to do a caffeine reset every few months by abstaining from it for about a week. While this period can be challenging and may feel unpleasant, it allows you to completely reset your caffeine tolerance. The upside is that you will likely experience improved sleep during this reset period.
Suggested Caffeine Supplement: COFFEE or PILLS
Garbage Supplements
1. Fat Burners & Fat Burning Ingredients
Most fat burners are overpriced caffeine pills:
Energy Expenditure and Hunger Reduction: While some ingredients like caffeine can slightly increase energy expenditure, most ingredients in fat burners lack solid evidence.
Raspberry Ketone: Effective in test tubes and animals, but no supporting human data.
Hoodia Gordonii: Claimed to suppress appetite but not proven in humans and may be mildly toxic.
Most mainstream fat burners are little more than overpriced caffeine pills. These products typically aim to boost fat loss by increasing energy expenditure and reducing hunger. While ingredients like caffeine have been shown to raise energy expenditure by up to 13%, the majority of other ingredients found in fat burners lack solid scientific backing. As a result, these products often fail to deliver on their promises.
2. Branch Chain Amino Acids (BCAAs)
BCAAs are popular but often unnecessary:
Limited Effectiveness: For individuals consuming adequate protein, BCAAs offer little, if any benefit at all. They may be helpful during calorie restriction or long periods without food, especially for vegetarians or vegans.
You might be surprised to see BCAAs on this list, given their popularity. While BCAAs can be effective during periods of calorie restriction or when you have long gaps between meals, they offer little benefit for those already consuming adequate protein. For most people who are eating sufficient calories and following a high-protein diet, BCAA supplementation is unnecessary. Instead, focus on consuming meals rich in high-quality proteins throughout the day. This approach is more efficient and cost-effective.
3. Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA)
CLA has shown mixed results:
Animal Studies vs. Human Studies: While CLA showed promising results in animals, human studies have not replicated these findings. CLA is often marketed for fat loss, but evidence in humans is lacking.
CLA is another popular supplement often touted for its fat loss benefits. Extensive research in both animal and human models has shown that CLA can have various biological effects, including anti-carcinogenesis, immune modulation, and changes in body composition. Initial animal studies were very promising, with one study showing that mice supplementing with CLA had 60% less body fat compared to the control group. However, while animal studies are useful for preliminary research, their results are not directly transferable to humans due to differences in metabolism. Consequently, the impressive results seen in animals have not been consistently replicated in human trials.
Choosing the Right Supplements
When choosing supplements, beware of companies that use proprietary blends. This practice hides the actual amounts of ingredients, allowing companies to include minimal effective doses while still making bold claims on their labels.
Conclusion
Navigating the supplement industry can be daunting. Stick to the few supplements that are backed by substantial scientific evidence: whey protein, creatine, and caffeine. These have proven benefits and are generally safe. Avoid the hype surrounding fat burners, BCAAs, and CLA unless you have specific dietary needs. Always prioritize whole foods and balanced nutrition over supplements, and consult with a healthcare provider before starting any new supplement regimen.
By understanding what works and what doesn't, you can make informed decisions and avoid wasting money on ineffective products. Remember, there is no magic pill for fitness—consistent effort, proper nutrition, and a well-designed exercise program are key to achieving your goals.